merclogo    
On Reality - Images, Experiences, and Distortions

     
   

 

Articles

Minamata-Table-01


Table 1

Members of Medical Study Group of Minamata Disease in Kumamoto University


Internal Medicine (Drs. Katuki and Tokuomi)
Pediatrics (Drs. Nagano, Kida and Harada)
Otorhinolaryngology (Dr. Nosaka)
Opthalmology (Dr. Okamura)
Psycho-Neurology (Drs. Miyagawa and Tatetsu)


Anatomy (Dr. Kutuna)
Pathology (Dr. Takeuchi)
Hygiene (Dr. Irukayama)
Public Health (Drs. Kitamura and Nomura)
Pharmacology (Drs. Uchida and Tanaka)

Table 2

Progress of the study of Minamata disease


1956 Apr. 215-year-old girl who complained various cerebral signs visited Dr. Noda.
May 28Anti-Minamata Disease Committee in Minamata City
Aug 24Medical Study Group in Kumamoto University was organized.
Epidemiological and clinical study
Post-mortem examination - 2 cases (adult cases)
Nov. 14Preliminary report: It may be intoxicative disease being caused by intake of fish and shellfish caught in Minamata Bay.

1957 Experimental study (given fish and shellfish to animal)
Study of extraction of causative agent from the fish and shellfish

1957 Sep. 26Post-mortem examination - 10 cases (post-natal cases)
Experimental study of methyl-mercuric compound
Organic mercury is most doubtful as the noxious factor (Medical Study Group)

1959 Jul. 22Official opinion of Medical Study Group: Organic mercury is causative agent.

1960-1962 Uchida isolated CH3HgSCH3 from Hormomya mutabilis
Irukayama and Kondo isolated CH3HgCl from Hormomya mutabilis and Venus Japonica
Irukayama isolated CH3HgCl from reaction tube of vinyl-acetate branch of Minamata Factory
Two and half year old girl with cerebral palsy died in 1961, and post-mortem examination was performed.
Medical Study Group accepted this case as congenital Minamata disease in 1961.


 

Table 3

Differential diagnosis of Minamata disease from the similar poisonings

Changes for differential
diagnosis
Minamata
disease
Organic
mercury
poisoning
Inorganic
mercury
poisoning
Thallium
poisoning
Manganese
poisoning

Nervous system
Loss of nerve cells
Cerebellar granular cells +++ +++ - - -
Area striata +++ +++ - - -
Cerebral cortex ++ ++ - - -
Cerebral nuclei + + + - +++
Softening ± ± ± ± ±
Disintegration of peripheral nerve ± ± ++ +++ -(+)
Hemorrhage, edema +++ +++ ++ ++ ++

Other organs
Degeneration of liver cells -(+) (+)- ++ + ++
Degeneration of kidney -(+) (+)- +++ ++ ±
Hypoplasia of bone marrow + + + - -
Inflammation of intestine + + +++ ++ -

Main clinical symptoms
Ataxia +++ +++ -(+) +++ +
Dysarthria +++ +++ + ± ±
Constriction of visual field +++ +++ - - -
Central scotoma - - - +++ -
Intelligent disturbance + + - + -
Pallidum syndrome (+) (+) + -(+) +++
Polyneuritic syndrome + + ++ +++ -
Disturbance in liver and kidney -(+) -(+) +++ ++ ++

 


On Reality. Publisher and editor: Bo Walhjalt. ISSN 1650-9323.
© Bo Walhjalt and authors. | Comments on this page
Latest update 2002-12-05

original url of this page: http://www.gbg.bonet.se/bwf/art/har/ts1.html